Tal Memorial R1: audio clips & game comments from the players
The Tal Memorial saw an attractive first round in Moscow today with four victories in five games. After Mamedyarov and Nakamura drew their game, Aronian was the first winner of the day against Kramnik. Karjakin scored the second point against Gelfand and then Wang Hao beat Shirov. In the longest game of the round Grischuk defeated Eljanov. We have audio clips with comments from all ten players.
General info
The traditional Tal Memorial tournament takes place 4-14 November in the GUM Exhibition Hall on Red Square, Moscow. Aronian (ARM, 2801), Kramnik (RUS, 2791), Alexander Grischuk (RUS 2771), Shakhriyar Mamedyarov (AZE, 2763), Sergey Karjakin (RUS, 2760), Pavel Eljanov (UKR, 2742), Boris Gelfand (ISR, 2741), Hikaru Nakamura (USA, 2741), Alexei Shirov (ESP, 2735) and Wang Hao (CHN, 2727) play a single round-robin. More info here.
Audio clips from the opening ceremony
After a somewhat modest (read: nothing special) opening ceremony the tournament started on Friday with a very exciting first round. But before we get to this, first some general remarks and comments from all ten players which Macauley Peterson & yours truly recorded at the reception after the opening ceremony.
Many participants have had a very tough schedule this fall, with a record streak of seven tournaments in a row for Alexei Shirov. Here's his comment at the opening ceremony - he starts with looking back at the Univé tournament in Hoogeveen.
[audio:http://www.chessvibes.com/audio/talmem10/opening/shirov.mp3]
Many others participated in the Olympiad and the European Club Cup or other events, such as the Corsica rapid tournament last week. This event, by the way, was won by Mamedyarov who beat his compatriot Radjabov in the final. Here you can listen to Mamedyarov's comment:
[audio:http://www.chessvibes.com/audio/talmem10/opening/mamedyarov.mp3]
Hikaru Nakamura's last event was the Cap d'Agde rapid tournament, where he lost to Vassily Ivanchuk in the final. After a brief comment on baseball, Nakamura talks about how negatively the French crowd reacted to him during that final, and a bit about his lot number 10 in the pairings.
[audio:http://www.chessvibes.com/audio/talmem10/opening/nakamura.mp3]
A while ago Alexander Grischuk stated that he much prefers to play blitz and rapid chess over classical chess. But recently he's been quite successful at top tournaments so we asked him if his attitude has changed a bit. He also comments on playing in his home town:
[audio:http://www.chessvibes.com/audio/talmem10/opening/grischuk.mp3]
Sergey Karjakin reached the top 10 of the FIDE rating list for the first time in his life, just a few days ago. He commented on this and, like Grischuk, to playing the Tal Memorial in his home town:
[audio:http://www.chessvibes.com/audio/talmem10/opening/karjakin.mp3]
Karjakin's former compatriot Pavel Eljanov feels strong, and doesn't know why he shouldn't be able to fight for first place:
[audio:http://www.chessvibes.com/audio/talmem10/opening/eljanov.mp3]
Boris Gelfand is happy to play at this great event, and comments on playing in Moscow and the tough schedule this fall:
[audio:http://www.chessvibes.com/audio/talmem10/opening/gelfand.mp3]
Wang Hao, who in fact already was in Moscow seven or eight times, also played chess just before the tournament. He was active in the Chinese club competition just days before he flew to Moscow. He commented on Chinese chess, and the possible pressure on him and Wang Yue to do well:
[audio:http://www.chessvibes.com/audio/talmem10/opening/wanghao.mp3]
Last year's winner Vladimir Kramnik declined to play in Nanjing because he already had committed himself to the Tal Memorial. In the audio clip he talks about his general feeling and activities since Bilbao and his expectations for the tournament, the rating race (which motivates him!) and the composition of the field:
[audio:http://www.chessvibes.com/audio/talmem10/opening/kramnik.mp3]
Levon Aronian is anxious, and feels he can win the tournament. He's not sure if playing many tournaments before this Tal Memorial is a real disadvantage, and finishes with a small tribute to the great Mikhail Nechemevich:
[audio:http://www.chessvibes.com/audio/talmem10/opening/aronian.mp3]

Round 1 report
Nakamura managed to surprise Mamedyarov by playing the very popular Lasker variation of the Queen's Gambit Declined. Black was comfortable right out of the opening and got an easy draw. The two players showed the game together in an improvised press room just next to the playing hall, on the second floor of the GUM department store. (The demo board needs to be lifted for the second round or otherwise players like Grischuk and Kramnik will surely start to complain about back problems before the rest day.)

Not long after that the top encounter, between the highest rated players in Moscow, finished. Levon Aronian wasn't satisfied about the way he got out of the opening, but towards the first time control his opponent Vladimir Kramnik played a few inaccurate moves and then the ending was lost. Well, that's what the players thought, as the computer found a tricky way to hold the position for Black just before the end.

Karjakin profited from a big mistake by Gelfand in a bishop ending. The young Moscovite demonstrated the subtleties of the ending on the demo board afterwards.

Grischuk joined the winners' club with a nice ending against Eljanov and Wang Hao took revenge for his unnecessary losses against Shirov in Shanghai. He seemed under pressure, but as a matter of fact he had played the same position against Hou Yifan recently with the white pieces and in the analysis they had found a way for Black to equalize.

As we were spending most of the day in the press room, we missed one saillant detail of this first round which chief arbiter Geurt Gijssen told us. Apparently there had been some activity on the Red Square preparing for the November 7 festivities, including tanks (!) and... lots of noise. Gijssen had ordered someone to buy ear plugs and most of the players did use them. "So far I haven't received official complaints from the players who lost today," said Gijssen.

Games round 1
Game viewer by ChessTempo

Link
Latest articles
-
4 hours 40 min ago
-
12 hours 25 min ago
-
1 day 9 hours ago
-
1 day 16 hours ago
-
2 days 9 hours ago
-
2 days 14 hours ago
-
2 days 14 hours ago
-
2 days 17 hours ago
-
3 days 4 hours ago
-
3 days 4 hours ago
-
4 days 6 hours ago
-
4 days 15 hours ago
-
5 days 8 hours ago
-
5 days 14 hours ago
-
6 days 7 hours ago
-
6 days 9 hours ago
-
6 days 14 hours ago
-
6 days 15 hours ago
-
1 week 5 hours ago
-
1 week 16 hours ago






Comments
Chesser
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
Aronian is a chess-hero
Kaushik
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
WoW!! wat an electric start to the tournamnet!! :)
john
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
Aronian becoming a monster!? Carlsen better watch his precious No. 1 rating spot lol
Daaim Shabazz
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
Anand is #1 right now.
Rinzou Wilkerson
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
Actually, Carlsen IS number one "right now". In the Live Ratings (liverating.org), Carlsen is 2811, Anand 2808, and Aronian 2801.
Matt
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
who cares about the live rating? Official rating is what it is calculated by the end of month and used officially in tournaments.
Accordingly, Anand is No.1. And Carlson has already chickened out of WC cycle. He knows he can beat tier-2 players but can not beat Aronian, Kramnik likes in a tournament consistently, so he got scared and the real Carlson came out!!!! If he wants to change the WC cycle system, then first go ahead, beat everyone and be a WC first, play like a MAN...and then offer himself to take part in qualifying matches like what he is talking about now...not like this...by withdrawing like a coward. :)
Rinzou Wilkerson
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
Who cares if YOU don't care? There are people out there who care even if you don't. The Live rating may not be "official", but it's the most up-to-date. Therefore, it's the most accurate.
Obviously you also don't care about spelling. It's Carlsen, not Carlson.
reality check
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
If you haven't yet noticed, most people don't take the fast food (LiveRating) too seriously. When one speaks of the World Champion or the World #1 we refer to Viswanathan Anand and the official FIDE rating. It just so happens Anand owns both titles now.
cip
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
I feel for Kramnik. He showed his preparation, had a winning shot *missed* and later blundered in time trouble and lost.
A double defeat and he must play quite a few games against Aronian in the coming future. He cannot be happy with the way things went today.
Serdal
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
Yes, I think it is Aronian's first win over Kramnik in a long time control. I've always wondered if he can make the step and beat guys from the top 5 (ok, he regularly beat Anand, at least with black), but I was afraid his slightly off-beat style was not quite suitable to beat players who are at least as strong as he is.
Hope he can continute this way, I like his style.
Serdal
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
After reviewing the game I have to relativize my comment. He was worse after the opening (again an exchange sac against Kramnik!) and proved to be one slippery fish, should only have made a draw at best, though.
Still, could be a psychological feat for the future (maybe in the Candidates, but to be honest, there's a good chance he'll go out against one of his nemeses, Gelfand).
S
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
If Karjakin could only play whites we would have a new world champion..;)
cip
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
Because if he could play only white, then the game would be different?
I am a moderate fan of him and I like some of his White games, but you're just asking to get flamed here. Didn't he lose against Magnus in a French?
S
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
No, because both the level and the results of his games with white are quite impressive for a while now. Something I just wanted to point out-notice the smiley.
S
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
According to the CB database Karjakin scores over 71 percent this year with white over 52 games.
World champion Anand scores 63 percent over 26 games.
Number one rated Carlsen scores 71 percent over 38 games.
Great white shark Kramnik has 72 percent with 38 games.
Aronian 67 percent, 44.
Topalov 62 percent, 25.
Looks to me like world class, especially with the number of games in mind.
If he can improve his results with black he may become a clear contender-for those that don't see him as one already.
cip
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
He, he :-) I don't mind the initial comment. Karjakin is one of the players I actually admire - quite an ok, hard working guy. I specially enjoyed his game against Eljanov in the recent Olympiad, flawless game/prep and entertaining to follow.
I just thought that with you mentioning "world champion", given the recent history, it might trigger an aggressive reaction. But I'm glad to see that people here have a good opinion of Karjakin.
(Btw, I appreciate the effort you put in the statistics, but they don't mean much without the average ELO of the opponents, although I'm sure they don't differ by that much. I would really like to see something along the lines of performance rating with the white pieces and with the black pieces separately - not that I ask it of you, but it would be interesting to see at what ELO ratings the performances with white start to differ significantly from those with black. Probably around 2500, but it's just a guess.)
S
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
@cip,
I did calculate the tprs (well CB did it for me) and I didn't mention them because they were somewhat lower for Karjakin than for Kramnik and Carlsen;)
The main reason for that was that he played more games including some against weaker players. But like you said, the difference in average elo of the opponents was not particulary high.
S
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
By the way, why do you only recall his loss against Magnus?
Don't be scared- I also respect him and a strong Karjakin won't take away Carlsen's greatness. But a single game is not really important for my observation.
Thomas
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
Apparently it's not your intention, but others claimed that Karjakin can _only_ play well with white - largely based on his very uneven color distribution at the Olympiad. So it might be worthwhile pointing out some of his other results this year:
- winning Poikovsky, a round robin event (6* black, 5* white)
- 5.5/7 at the Russian Club Cup Premier League despite 5 blacks, beating 2700ers Motylev and Eljanov with the black pieces [no idea if excess blacks were a tactical decision by the team captain, or if it "just happened"]
- Corus 2010: yes he lost against Carlsen with white, AND he beat Nakamura with the black pieces.
BTW, the 52 games in the CB database must include rapid and maybe blitz or blindfold (Amber this year) - according to the FIDE rating pages, he played 47 rated games _in total_ this year.
S
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
Thanks, there are indeed some rapid games in the numbers as he won a strong rapid tournament in the Ukraine (rapid and blind may also be included in the numbers of other players).
And of course he can win with any colour. But for a long time it seemed that there was indeed a difference in his play with white and black. Or maybe he is just quickly satisfied with a draw as black. I am not sure if this shows in his results and since I am not a strong player I may be totally wrong.
I also think he has a bit limited opening repertoire.
And then there are games like his loss against Korobov or his win against Riazantsev, where he is quickly lost after a bad opening.
vladimirOo
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
It seems to me that Karjakin has always played 1.e4, therefore he may have better experience and confidence with this weapon (i wonder if other player aren't starting to get unaccustomed to 1.e4 since 1.d4 is the main weapon of the Big men, Topalov aswell).
On the contrary, he is a bit hesitating with his black repertoire: sometimes the Ruy Lopez, sometimes the Sicilian... And against 1.d4, i really do not know what he might be inclined to play, he is always uncertain...
analyse
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
did shirov not give up to early? the position is only -0.50 for white after move 51.
how to win this endgame??
st32
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
@analyse: Black has the simple plan of playing Rf5 and then bringing the king to d5, then taking e5. Which leads me to ask why Kh6 was played.. was tht really played?
analyse
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
@st32,
yes right the white pawn e5 is weak. OK, so the chessengine was bad or to slow.
archknight
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
Kramnik is finished as one of the top three forces in chess. Aronian has arrived!
Barthod
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
Nonsense
Aronian not in same class as Kramnik and very lucky to beat Kramnik in the first round.
Thomas
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
Both of you are at least simplistic: How can a single game (where all three results were possible at various stages) conclusively determine who's the better player? True, it amplified the gap on the live rating list between #3 and #4 - which would have almost disappeared with a Kramnik win.
sundararajan ganesan
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
how fitting to see decisive games in the "Tal Memorial" tournaments!
cak
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
Because of his many short draws in the early 70's? :)
He also has some very short wins:
http://www.chessgames.com/perl/chessgame?gid=1140092
suplexer
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
Is world number 1 vishy anand at this tournament?
flshstar
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
@suplexer, seems to me Anand pick and chose the tournaments he plays and just sit out a lot of tournaments to preserve his rating. He did not play in the Olympic where Carlsen lost a lot of his ratings. Anand as world champion doesn't play like a champion and win some tournaments like the past world champions.
Thomas
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
You may have a point about the Olympiad - whatever Anand's reasons are to skip it this year and several times in the past, serious disagreements with the Indian federation? But for Tal Memorial: It takes place right after Nanjing. Anand, Carlsen and Kramnik were all invited to both events and chose one declining the other. Even super-GMs cannot play constantly all the time - Shirov does at the moment and seems to pay the prize in Moscow. And he stayed in Europe (Plovdiv, Bilbao, Hoogeveen, now Moscow) so jetlag doesn't play a role ... .
reality check
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
Simple minded people will never understand this but for what ever its worth, Viswanathan Anand is the current World Champion and World #1.
The various ratings lists don't apply to him as they do to WCC contenders because he has the "UltimateRating" by way of owning the WCC Title!!!
The LiveRating is only important to people like the current World #2 Carlsen who've never been WCC, never experienced the "UltimateRating" and need an indice showing their position in relation to the other candidates.
victor pastrana
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
WATCH OUT Magnus!!!! Here comes GM Aronian
choufleur
2 years 7 months ago
Permalink
in the comment of Aronian-Kramnik
"with the neat pointe 41... Rxg2+!"
this does not seem necessary, indeed 41... b1Q is an obvious and immediate draw by perpetual check. Strange that the players missed this quite obvious idea, maybe the lack of time ?
Your comment
By posting a comment you are agreeing to abide our Terms & Conditions