Carlsen beats Caruana 2-0 in playoff, wins 5th Masters Final
In an unexpected scenario on the last day, Magnus Carlsen won the 5th Masters Final in Bilbao. The final round started with a 19-move draw between Fabiano Caruana and Paco Vallejo, who went for a famous move repetition in the Zaitsev Ruy Lopez. Carlsen drew his game with Levon Aronian to finish shared first. The Norwegian then won both games in a blitz playoff to retain his title in Bilbao.
Magnus Carlsen is the winner! | Photos provided by the organizers
The night before the last round, after his very disappointing loss against Karjakin, Paco Vallejo posted a status update on Facebook which caused a storm of reactions. Normally we refrain from publishing private messages, but in the meantime it has been discussed widely online and also by Vallejo himself, with Leontxo Garcia, in Saturday's press conference.
Well, today another ridiculous game. Thanks people for the encouragement. But I decided that I retire from competitive chess indefinitely (obviously I will respect some commitments, luckily [there are] not many).
This explained, at least partly, the 19-move draw between Vallejo (with White!) against Caruana. The Italian played the Zaitsev Ruy Lopez, and the Spaniard forced tablas with Nf3-g5-f3-g5, a well known theoretical move repetition.
Vallejo vs Caruana, with the Zaitsev position on the board
Vallejo first gave chess technical reasons for his decision (for which he spent, by the way, 19 minutes on the clock), but then made clear that there was more to it.
I did not expect him to play the Zaitsev. I tried to remember my analysis and I felt that I did not remember it well enough. But besides the chess reasons... after a tournament this difficult, this cruel, especially the last couple of games, it was difficult to motivate myself. My general state of mind is not very optimistic right now.
About his Facebook message, Vallejo said:
I still have some games to play, for example for the Bundesliga, for the Catalan team, and I also qualified for the World Cup which I will play of course. This was not a decision that was made on the fly. Yesterday it was a very tough game, I had so many good options. You know, when you realize you are making the same mistakes over and over again, there comes a moment when you have to make a decision. I think it's a good idea to take some rest and quit playing for about five years. I haven't spent two full months with my family for the last twenty years. I think I have the right to do things that I haven't been able to do. I think I will return to chess at some point, but I don't know exactly when. I don't think I will leave chess, in fact I think will continue to train. One of the reasons to retire for a while is to improve certain aspects of my play.
Caruana was also asked about the quick draw, with which he risked dropping to second place, if Carlsen would beat Aronian.
I didn't actually expect to make a draw this fast; I was expecting it to be a big fight. I was actually looking before the game not how to win but first how to get a normal position. Of course after I choose this opening, the Zaitsev, I don't really have chances to avoid it if White wants to make a draw. Instead of ...Re8 I guess there is the move ...h6 or ...Nd7 but all these lines are quite dubious I think. Of course if I'd play recklessly I could easily be punished.
The last round under way in Bilbao
The second game to finish was Anand vs Karjakin - a great battle right from the start. It looked like for the first time in the tournament Anand went "all in", as if he wanted to take more risks than ever to finish his tournament on a 50% score. In reality this game could have been played in any round, because Anand was mostly repeating a sharp line which he played earlier this year.
My position looked a little bit scary but probably I was fine.
I saw many entertaining ideas, but there was never a concrete win.
About his loss against Carlsen, the World Champ said:
Yesterday was a big disappointment. I reached a position where I had absolutely no problems, and then I spoilt everything in two or three moves.
On the last day all the players were asked the same question by Leontxo Garcia: "Do you feel like a sportsman, a scientist or an artist?" The spectators laughed loudly when Anand answered:
You feel like a sportsman every day. Sometimes you feel like a scientist, sometimes you feel like an artist and sometimes you feel like an imbecile.
Magnus Carlsen never got close to an advantage with Black, let alone to breaking Garry Kasparov's rating record.
Aronian vs Carlsen, drawn in 44 moves
This meant that Carlsen and Caruana were still tied for first after the last round. This year the regulations stated that a blitz playoff would decide upon the winner: two blitz games (4 minutes plus 3 seconds increment) and in case of 1-1, an Armageddon (5 minutes against 4).
A blitz playoff between Carlsen and Caruana
Before the playoff, Karjakin said that for him Carlsen was the big favorite.
In my view Caruana made a big mistake by drawing his game so quickly. He had to try to win against Paco.
And indeed, Carlsen won this playoff most convincingly: he beat Caruana 2-0. In the first game he played the Berlin Ending.
Carlsen starts with a win in the infamous Berlin Ending
In the second game Caruana was caught in the opening: as early as move 10 he couldn't avoid the loss of material. The sort of thing that just happens every now and then in a blitz game...
Obviously there was a huge interest from the spectators for the blitz playoff
And so Carlsen won yet another tournament. That's almost no news anymore!
Caruana played one of his best tournaments ever, but asked about this he put things in perspective:
By performance it might be the best tournament, but I felt I played better in a few others, like Wijk aan Zee at the beginning of this year. I also think I played better in the second half, where I only scored 50%, than in the first half.
A final group photo of the players
Grand Slam Masters Final 2012 | Schedule & results
|Round 1||24.09.12||20:00 CET||Round 6||08.10.12||17:00 CET|
|Round 2||25.09.12||20:00 CET||Round 7||09.10.12||17:00 CET|
|Round 3||26.09.12||20:00 CET||Round 8||11.10.12||17:00 CET|
|Round 4||28.09.12||20:00 CET||Round 9||12.10.12||17:00 CET|
|Round 5||29.09.12||20:00 CET||Round 10||13.10.12||16:30 CET|
Grand Slam Masters Final 2012 | Round 10 standings (football)
Grand Slam Masters Final 2012 | Round 10 standings (classical)
5 hours 3 min ago
2 days 3 hours ago
2 days 15 hours ago
3 days 17 hours ago
4 days 6 hours ago
4 days 19 hours ago
5 days 21 hours ago
6 days 19 hours ago
1 week 12 hours ago
1 week 19 hours ago
1 week 1 day ago
1 week 2 days ago
1 week 2 days ago
1 week 2 days ago
1 week 3 days ago
1 week 4 days ago
1 week 5 days ago
1 week 6 days ago
2 weeks 11 hours ago
2 weeks 1 day ago