Reports | July 22, 2010 6:52

Dortmund R6: Naiditsch beats Mamedyarov, other games drawn

Naiditsch (c) Georgios SouleidisAfter yesterday's rest day, Arkadij Naiditsch scored his first victory of the tournament while the other two games ended in relatively quiet draws.

In today's round, Naiditsch did excellent business after a slightly bleak tournament so far, while Ponomariov and Le Quang consolidated their leading positions.

Le Quang had pretty good chances today against Kramnik after some fine opening preparation. In a topical line of the Catalan Defence, the Vietnamese had prepared a novelty that got Kramnik thinking.

After 16 moves of well-known theory, the following position was reached:

Instead of the still known 17.Nxd7 (Dominguez-Carlsen, Nizza 2010), Le Quang played 17.Rac1! - a move he said afterwards to have found at home - after which White retained his slight but certain opening advantage. A couple of moves later, Kramnik faced an 'octopus' on d6 which got him in some serious (practical) trouble.

21...c4? (21...f6! had to be played - Le Quang) 22.b3! after which White opened the c-file with a huge positional plus. Sadly for Le Quang, he let his advantage slip away and the Russian managed to flee into a drawish endgame where his bishop and rook proved sufficiently solid against Le Quang's queen. A narrow escape for Kramnik!

Le Quang - Kramnik (photo by Georgios Souleidis)

Ponomariov never really got into trouble against Leko in yet another Catalan variation. Optically, it looked a bit tricky for Black at some point, but Pono was apparently just in time to free his bishop and get his counterplay going.

Leko - Ponomariov (photo by Georgios Souleidis)

Obviously, it's not Peter Leko's tournament so far, especially not after Naiditsch passed him in the standings today.

Actually, the German was "lucky" to beat Mamedyarov - except that there is no such thing as luck in chess, of course. Still, it must be admitted that White was better during most of the game. Consider the position after Naiditsch has just played 24...Qb2:

Here, the machine suggests 25.Qd3! with a big advantage in all lines. On 25...Qb7, White continues with the logical 26.Ng4 and 27.f4 with a strong attack, while 25...Rc6 runs into 26.Rab1 Rxc1+ 27.Bxc1 Qa2 28.Ng4 Kg7 29.Rb7 with a very nasty initiative for White. However, Mamedyarov played 25.Nf3 after which Black seemed to be OK again, until Black mistakenly exchanged rooks and White was back in the driver's seat.

Mamedyarov again decided to make a knight move (32.Nh2) but 32.Bxg5! looks absolutely killing since after multiple captures on g5, the black rook will be left hanging on d8, and after 32...Qb6 White has the extremely difficult-to-find 33.Bf6! Rg8 34.Ng5+!! followed by Qd3+ and Rxd7 with a winning game.

Instead of this, Mamedyarov totally ruined his day when a few moves later he committed a really horrible blunder:

Now 36.Qd3+ looks about equal, but here the Azeri suddenly played 36.Rxd7?? and resigned furiously without waiting for the obvious. A small tragedy, indeed.

Mamedyarov - Naiditsch (photo by Georgios Souleidis)

Standings after 6 rounds:

1. Ponomariov 4
2. Le Quang 3,5
3. Mamedyarov, Kramnik 3
5. Naiditsch 2,5
6. Leko 2

Games start daily at 15.00 CET and can be followed live here.

Dortmund Games round 6

Game viewer by ChessTempo

Links

Share |
Arne Moll's picture
Author: Arne Moll

Once an ambitious chess youngster studying Russian literature, Arne now is a "semi-retired" chess enthusiast working in the banking industry, writing columns and book reviews for ChessVibes in his spare time.

SmartChess! - Revolutionize your game

World Youth Under 16 Chess Olympiad

Comments

ChessGirl's picture

poor Mamedyarov :(

john's picture

couldn't have happened to a nicer guy

Serdal's picture

We should cut Mamedyarov some slack for not playing 32.Bxg5!. After 32... Bxg5 33.Nxg5+ hxg5 34.Qxg5 Qe2 35.Qxd8 it is very hard to see that white can escape the perpetual check. But he has to find (among other lines) 35....Qd1+ 36. Kh2 Qxh5+ 37. Kg3 Qg6+ 38. Kh3 Qf5+ 39. Kh4 Qe4+ 40.f4!!.
And he has to calculate that from the diagram position above. That's practically impossible.

noyb's picture

I'd like to say what happened to Mamedyarov has never happened to me. I'd like to, but I can't.

ChessGirl's picture
Serdal's picture

Sorry, I spoke too early. 40.f4 in the line above would still lead to a perpetual check after 40...Nxe5!. Instead, white can try 40.g4 when 40...Qh1+ 41.Kg3 Qg1+ 42.Kf3 Qd1+ 43. Kf4 Qxd4+ 44.Kg3 Nxe5. There could follow 45.Qg5 Qa1 46. Rc1 Qa3+ 47. Qe3. My impression is that the endgame after the queen swap is drawish as long black doesn't take on e3 himself (when white could use the pawn to soften up black's knight outpost on c4 by e4). So, I guess 47... Nc4! would make for a holdable position for black.
If white doesn't have anything better on move 35, the sacrifice might not work entirely. Maybe it does, but my original point is still valid, I think, these complications can't be calculated with 30 mins on the clock.

iLane's picture

I wonder what did he see for Black after 25. Qd3, it was so nice and obvious move! :o

Thomas's picture

@Serdal: Dennis Monokroussos on Chessmind gives lines similar to yours - with the irrelevant difference that he starts with 34.-Qd3.

I guess his earlier comment makes perfect sense: "30...Rxc7? This is a mistake, but White must play like a genius to prove it."

sjw's picture

Ouch! But Mamedyarov's certainly not the first-- you could put together a book of blunders where strong players missed diagonally backward moves. (Starting with this one, I suppose: http://www.chessgames.com/perl/chessgame?gid=1162749 . White's 40th move there has just one tiny little flaw...)

-sjw

Your comment

Speak your mind

By posting a comment you are agreeing to abide our Terms & Conditions