Tata R11: Aronian loses to Navara, still leads by half a point

Tail-ender David Navara surprised everyone today by beating tournament leader Levon Aronian with the black pieces in Wijk aan Zee, The Netherlands. In a very exciting game not without mistakes, Magnus Carlsen defeated Veselin Topalov to keep his chances for tournament victory alive. With two rounds to go at the 74th Tata Steel tournament the Norwegian shares second place with Teimour Radjabov, who won against his compatriot Vugar Gashimov.
|
The 74th Tata Steel tournament saw a fantastic round on Friday full of surprises and great games everywhere. The tournament leader went down, the world's number one was probably lost somewhere but emerged as the winner, and in total just one game ended in a draw in the A group. Furthermore, the leader in the B group lost a spectacular game while in the C group things are exciting as well with two co-leaders and two rounds to go. A better starting point for a thrilling final weekend of chess in Wijk aan Zee can hardly be imagined!
We start with the biggest upset of the tournament: tail-ender David Navara beating tournament leader Levon Aronian, with the black pieces. It was the first win for Navara, who got the 500-euro ‘Piet Zwart Prize’ for it. It started with excellent preparation by him and his second Vlastimil Jansa, involving the move 11...Na6. Black was better in the ending that resulted, and so Navara declined an early draw offer by Aronian.
I was looking at the best position I had in the whole course of the tournament!
Navara said during the press conference, which you can watch here. Besides Navara's own explanation we highly recommend checking the live commentary by GM Ian Rogers, who will be providing this during the final three rounds.

However, we're not even sure if we should call this fight the game of the day, because Magnus Carlsen and Veselin Topalov fought out a fierce battle as well. The world's number one won it, but wasn't happy about his play. Right after the opening he blundered a pawn, but in return he got a dangerous attack. According to the Houdini evaluations Topalov was winning at some point, and former winner GM John Nunn, who is in Wijk aan Zee to participate in two solving competitions, didn't see how White would mate his opponent either.

John Nunn of England
However, over the board it was extremely difficult of course. Topalov kept good drawing chances for a long time, but eventually Carlsen won, and kept his chances alive to win the 74th edition.
Press conference Magnus Carlsen
Carlsen-Topalov was followed closely by Vladimir Kramnik, who suddenly entered the press room in Wijk aan Zee during the round! As it turned out, the ex-World Champion was to sign a contract later that evening together with Levon Aronian and a sponsor, for a 6-game match (classical games!) in the last week of April. More details will be announced soon.

Vladimir Kramnik, a welcome guest in the press room during the 11th round
Anish Giri is having a tough time, with a series of losses. On Friday he lost to Fabiano Caruana, who got three passed pawns in return for a piece.

Gata Kamsky and Hikaru Nakamura played the only draw of the round, in a 9.0-0-0 Dragon. Loek van Wely ended his drawing streak with a loss against Sergey Karjakin, who still only drew one game! In the derby between the two grandmasters from Azerbaijan, Teimour Radjabov defeated Vugar Gashimov with Black. It was an important win because now Radjabov is still sharing second place with Carlsen. This cannot be said about Vassily Ivanchuk, who lost thread in a completely equal position.

The tournament leader in the B group, Pentala Harikrishna, suffered his first loss, against Sipke Ernst. It was a spectacular game in which Ernst used Aronian's idea of h4&g4 in the Lasker QGD.

This gave Erwin l'Ami and Alexander Motylev the chance to catch Harikrishna in first place, but they drew their mutual game and so they're both still half a point behind.
In the C group, Hans Tikkanen again caught Maxim Turov in first place. The Swedish grandmaster beat Sahaj Grover while Turov drew with Brandenburg.
Daily video by the organizers
Games group A, round 11
Tata Steel 2012 | Grandmaster Group A | Pairings
| Round 1 | 14.01.12 | 13.30 CET | Round 2 | 15.01.12 | 13.30 CET | |
| Navara | ½-½ | Topalov | Topalov | ½-½ | Van Wely | |
| Gelfand | 0-1 | Giri | Gashimov | ½-½ | Kamsky | |
| Radjabov | ½-½ | Caruana | Ivanchuk | ½-½ | Carlsen | |
| Karjakin | 0-1 | Aronian | Aronian | 1-0 | Nakamura | |
| Nakamura | ½-½ | Ivanchuk | Caruana | 1-0 | Karjakin | |
| Carlsen | 1-0 | Gashimov | Giri | ½-½ | Radjabov | |
| Kamsky | ½-½ | Van Wely | Navara | ½-½ | Gelfand | |
| Round 3 | 16.01.12 | 13.30 CET | Round 4 | 17.01.12 | 13.30 CET | |
| Gelfand | ½-½ | Topalov | Topalov | ½-½ | Gashimov | |
| Radjabov | 1-0 | Navara | Ivanchuk | ½-½ | Van Wely | |
| Karjakin | 1-0 | Giri | Aronian | 1-0 | Kamsky | |
| Nakamura | ½-½ | Caruana | Caruana | ½-½ | Carlsen | |
| Carlsen | 1-0 | Aronian | Giri | ½-½ | Nakamura | |
| Kamsky | ½-½ | Ivanchuk | Navara | 0-1 | Karjakin | |
| Van Wely | ½-½ | Gashimov | Gelfand | ½-½ | Radjabov | |
| Round 5 | 19.01.12 | 13.30 CET | Round 6 | 20.01.12 | 13.30 CET | |
| Radjabov | ½-½ | Topalov | Topalov | ½-½ | Ivanchuk | |
| Karjakin | 0-1 | Gelfand | Aronian | 1-0 | Gashimov | |
| Nakamura | 1-0 | Navara | Caruana | ½-½ | Van Wely | |
| Carlsen | ½-½ | Giri | Giri | 1-0 | Kamsky | |
| Kamsky | ½-½ | Caruana | Navara | ½-½ | Carlsen | |
| Van Wely | ½-½ | Aronian | Gelfand | 0-1 | Nakamura | |
| Gashimov | 0-1 | Ivanchuk | Radjabov | 1-0 | Karjakin | |
| Round 7 | 21.01.12 | 13.30 CET | Round 8 | 22.01.12 | 13.30 CET | |
| Karjakin | 1-0 | Topalov | Topalov | ½-½ | Aronian | |
| Nakamura | ½-½ | Radjabov | Caruana | ½-½ | Ivanchuk | |
| Carlsen | 1-0 | Gelfand | Giri | 0-1 | Gashimov | |
| Kamsky | 1-0 | Navara | Navara | ½-½ | Van Wely | |
| Van Wely | ½-½ | Giri | Gelfand | ½-½ | Kamsky | |
| Gashimov | ½-½ | Caruana | Radjabov | ½-½ | Carlsen | |
| Ivanchuk | ½-½ | Aronian | Karjakin | ½-½ | Nakamura | |
| Round 9 | 24.01.12 | 13.30 CET | Round 10 | 25.01.12 | 13.30 CET | |
| Nakamura | ½-½ | Topalov | Topalov | 0-1 | Caruana | |
| Carlsen | 0-1 | Karjakin | Giri | 0-1 | Aronian | |
| Kamsky | ½-½ | Radjabov | Navara | 0-1 | Ivanchuk | |
| Van Wely | ½-½ | Gelfand | Gelfand | ½-½ | Gashimov | |
| Gashimov | ½-½ | Navara | Radjabov | ½-½ | Van Wely | |
| Ivanchuk | 1-0 | Giri | Karjakin | 0-1 | Kamsky | |
| Aronian | 1-0 | Caruana | Nakamura | ½-½ | Carlsen | |
| Round 11 | 27.01.12 | 13.30 CET | Round 12 | 28.01.12 | 13.30 CET | |
| Carlsen | 1-0 | Topalov | Topalov | - | Giri | |
| Kamsky | ½-½ | Nakamura | Navara | - | Caruana | |
| Van Wely | 0-1 | Karjakin | Gelfand | - | Aronian | |
| Gashimov | 0-1 | Radjabov | Radjabov | - | Ivanchuk | |
| Ivanchuk | 0-1 | Gelfand | Karjakin | - | Gashimov | |
| Aronian | 0-1 | Navara | Nakamura | - | Van Wely | |
| Caruana | 1-0 | Giri | Carlsen | - | Kamsky | |
| Round 13 | 29.01.12 | 12.00 CET | ||||
| Kamsky | - | Topalov | ||||
| Van Wely | - | Carlsen | ||||
| Gashimov | - | Nakamura | ||||
| Ivanchuk | - | Karjakin | ||||
| Aronian | - | Radjabov | ||||
| Caruana | - | Gelfand | ||||
| Giri | - | Navara |
Tata Steel 2012 | Grandmaster Group A | Round 11 standings
Games group B, round 11
Tata Steel 2012 | Grandmaster Group B | Pairings
| Round 1 | 14.01.12 | 13.30 CET | Round 2 | 15.01.12 | 13.30 CET | |
| Reinderman | ½-½ | Motylev | Motylev | ½-½ | Potkin | |
| Bruzon | 0-1 | Harikrishna | Tiviakov | 1-0 | Timman | |
| Lahno | 1-0 | Ernst | Nyzhnyk | ½-½ | l'Ami | |
| Harika | ½-½ | Vocaturo | Vocaturo | 1-0 | Cmilyte | |
| Cmilyte | 0-1 | Nyzhnyk | Ernst | ½-½ | Harika | |
| l'Ami | 1-0 | Tiviakov | Harikrishna | 1-0 | Lahno | |
| Timman | ½-½ | Potkin | Reinderman | ½-½ | Bruzon | |
| Round 3 | 16.01.12 | 13.30 CET | Round 4 | 17.01.12 | 13.30 CET | |
| Bruzon | ½-½ | Motylev | Motylev | 1-0 | Tiviakov | |
| Lahno | ½-½ | Reinderman | Nyzhnyk | ½-½ | Potkin | |
| Harika | 0-1 | Harikrishna | Vocaturo | ½-½ | Timman | |
| Cmilyte | 1-0 | Ernst | Ernst | 1-0 | l'Ami | |
| l'Ami | 1-0 | Vocaturo | Harikrishna | ½-½ | Cmilyte | |
| Timman | 1-0 | Nyzhnyk | Reinderman | ½-½ | Harika | |
| Potkin | 0-1 | Tiviakov | Bruzon | ½-½ | Lahno | |
| Round 5 | 19.01.12 | 13.30 CET | Round 6 | 20.01.12 | 13.30 CET | |
| Lahno | 0-1 | Motylev | Motylev | ½-½ | Nyzhnyk | |
| Harika | 0-1 | Bruzon | Vocaturo | ½-½ | Tiviakov | |
| Cmilyte | ½-½ | Reinderman | Ernst | 1-0 | Potkin | |
| l'Ami | ½-½ | Harikrishna | Harikrishna | 1-0 | Timman | |
| Timman | 1-0 | Ernst | Reinderman | ½-½ | l'Ami | |
| Potkin | ½-½ | Vocaturo | Bruzon | 1-0 | Cmilyte | |
| Tiviakov | ½-½ | Nyzhnyk | Lahno | ½-½ | Harika | |
| Round 7 | 21.01.12 | 13.30 CET | Round 8 | 22.01.12 | 13.30 CET | |
| Harika | ½-½ | Motylev | Motylev | 1-0 | Vocaturo | |
| Cmilyte | ½-½ | Lahno | Ernst | ½-½ | Nyzhnyk | |
| l'Ami | ½-½ | Bruzon | Harikrishna | ½-½ | Tiviakov | |
| Timman | 0-1 | Reinderman | Reinderman | 0-1 | Potkin | |
| Potkin | ½-½ | Harikrishna | Bruzon | 1-0 | Timman | |
| Tiviakov | 0-1 | Ernst | Lahno | 0-1 | l'Ami | |
| Nyzhnyk | 1-0 | Vocaturo | Harika | ½-½ | Cmilyte | |
| Round 9 | 24.01.12 | 13.30 CET | Round 10 | 25.01.12 | 13.30 CET | |
| Cmilyte | ½-½ | Motylev | Motylev | 1-0 | Ernst | |
| l'Ami | 1-0 | Harika | Harikrishna | 1-0 | Vocaturo | |
| Timman | ½-½ | Lahno | Reinderman | 1-0 | Nyzhnyk | |
| Potkin | 0-1 | Bruzon | Bruzon | ½-½ | Tiviakov | |
| Tiviakov | 1-0 | Reinderman | Lahno | ½-½ | Potkin | |
| Nyzhnyk | 0-1 | Harikrishna | Harika | ½-½ | Timman | |
| Vocaturo | 1-0 | Ernst | Cmilyte | 0-1 | l'Ami | |
| Round 11 | 27.01.12 | 13.30 CET | Round 12 | 28.01.12 | 13.30 CET | |
| l'Ami | ½-½ | Motylev | Motylev | - | Harikrishna | |
| Timman | 1-0 | Cmilyte | Reinderman | - | Ernst | |
| Potkin | 1-0 | Harika | Bruzon | - | Vocaturo | |
| Tiviakov | 1-0 | Lahno | Lahno | - | Nyzhnyk | |
| Nyzhnyk | 1-0 | Bruzon | Harika | - | Tiviakov | |
| Vocaturo | 0-1 | Reinderman | Cmilyte | - | Potkin | |
| Ernst | 1-0 | Harikrishna | l'Ami | - | Timman | |
| Round 13 | 29.01.12 | 12.00 CET | ||||
| Timman | - | Motylev | ||||
| Potkin | - | l'Ami | ||||
| Tiviakov | - | Cmilyte | ||||
| Nyzhnyk | - | Harika | ||||
| Vocaturo | - | Lahno | ||||
| Ernst | - | Bruzon | ||||
| Harikrishna | - | Reinderman |
Tata Steel 2012 | Grandmaster Group B | Round 11 standings
Games group C, round 11
Tata Steel 2012 | Grandmaster Group C | Pairings
| Round 1 | 14.01.12 | 13.30 CET | Round 2 | 15.01.12 | 13.30 CET | |
| Sadler | 1-0 | Hopman | Hopman | 0-1 | Turov | |
| Tania | ½-½ | Grover | Schut | ½-½ | Danielian | |
| Paehtz | 0-1 | Tikkanen | Haast | ½-½ | Goudriaan | |
| Brandenburg | ½-½ | Ootes | Ootes | ½-½ | Adhiban | |
| Adhiban | 1-0 | Haast | Tikkanen | ½-½ | Brandenburg | |
| Goudriaan | 1-0 | Schut | Grover | 1-0 | Paehtz | |
| Danielian | 0-1 | Turov | Sadler | ½-½ | Tania | |
| Round 3 | 16.01.12 | 13.30 CET | Round 4 | 17.01.12 | 13.30 CET | |
| Tania | ½-½ | Hopman | Hopman | 0-1 | Schut | |
| Paehtz | ½-½ | Sadler | Haast | 0-1 | Turov | |
| Brandenburg | ½-½ | Grover | Ootes | 1-0 | Danielian | |
| Adhiban | ½-½ | Tikkanen | Tikkanen | 1-0 | Goudriaan | |
| Goudriaan | 1-0 | Ootes | Grover | 0-1 | Adhiban | |
| Danielian | ½-½ | Haast | Sadler | ½-½ | Brandenburg | |
| Turov | 1-0 | Schut | Tania | 0-1 | Paehtz | |
| Round 5 | 19.01.12 | 13.30 CET | Round 6 | 20.01.12 | 13.30 CET | |
| Paehtz | ½-½ | Hopman | Hopman | 1-0 | Haast | |
| Brandenburg | ½-½ | Tania | Ootes | 0-1 | Schut | |
| Adhiban | ½-½ | Sadler | Tikkanen | ½-½ | Turov | |
| Goudriaan | 0-1 | Grover | Grover | ½-½ | Danielian | |
| Danielian | 0-1 | Tikkanen | Sadler | ½-½ | Goudriaan | |
| Turov | 1-0 | Ootes | Tania | ½-½ | Adhiban | |
| Schut | 1-0 | Haast | Paehtz | ½-½ | Brandenburg | |
| Round 7 | 21.01.12 | 13.30 CET | Round 8 | 22.01.12 | 13.30 CET | |
| Brandenburg | 1-0 | Hopman | Hopman | 0-1 | Ootes | |
| Adhiban | 1-0 | Paehtz | Tikkanen | 1-0 | Haast | |
| Goudriaan | ½-½ | Tania | Grover | 1-0 | Schut | |
| Danielian | ½-½ | Sadler | Sadler | ½-½ | Turov | |
| Turov | ½-½ | Grover | Tania | ½-½ | Danielian | |
| Schut | 0-1 | Tikkanen | Paehtz | 1-0 | Goudriaan | |
| Haast | 1-0 | Ootes | Brandenburg | ½-½ | Adhiban | |
| Round 9 | 24.01.12 | 13.30 CET | Round 10 | 25.01.12 | 13.30 CET | |
| Adhiban | 1-0 | Hopman | Hopman | 1-0 | Tikkanen | |
| Goudriaan | ½-½ | Brandenburg | Grover | 1-0 | Ootes | |
| Danielian | ½-½ | Paehtz | Sadler | 1-0 | Haast | |
| Turov | 1-0 | Tania | Tania | 1-0 | Schut | |
| Schut | ½-½ | Sadler | Paehtz | ½-½ | Turov | |
| Haast | 1-0 | Grover | Brandenburg | 1-0 | Danielian | |
| Ootes | 0-1 | Tikkanen | Adhiban | ½-½ | Goudriaan | |
| Round 11 | 27.01.12 | 13.30 CET | Round 12 | 28.01.12 | 13.30 CET | |
| Goudriaan | ½-½ | Hopman | Hopman | - | Grover | |
| Danielian | ½-½ | Adhiban | Sadler | - | Tikkanen | |
| Turov | ½-½ | Brandenburg | Tania | - | Ootes | |
| Schut | 0-1 | Paehtz | Paehtz | - | Haast | |
| Haast | 0-1 | Tania | Brandenburg | - | Schut | |
| Ootes | ½-½ | Sadler | Adhiban | - | Turov | |
| Tikkanen | 1-0 | Grover | Goudriaan | - | Danielian | |
| Round 13 | 29.01.12 | 12.00 CET | ||||
| Danielian | - | Hopman | ||||
| Turov | - | Goudriaan | ||||
| Schut | - | Adhiban | ||||
| Haast | - | Brandenburg | ||||
| Ootes | - | Paehtz | ||||
| Tikkanen | - | Tania | ||||
| Grover | - | Sadler |
Tata Steel 2012 | Grandmaster Group C | Round 11 standings
Latest articles
-
14 hours 44 min ago
-
1 day 10 hours ago
-
1 day 13 hours ago
-
2 days 9 hours ago
-
3 days 12 hours ago
-
3 days 12 hours ago
-
3 days 23 hours ago
-
4 days 10 hours ago
-
4 days 15 hours ago
-
4 days 21 hours ago
-
5 days 11 hours ago
-
5 days 18 hours ago
-
6 days 9 hours ago
-
6 days 18 hours ago
-
6 days 18 hours ago
-
1 week 7 hours ago
-
1 week 1 day ago
-
1 week 1 day ago
-
1 week 2 days ago
-
1 week 2 days ago











Comments
Anonymous
1 year 3 months ago
Permalink
Kamsky-Naka was not a 9.Qe1 Dragon. Perhaps you meant the 10.Qe1 line, but it was not that line either....
Peter Doggers
1 year 3 months ago
Permalink
Thanks, corrected. I meant the 9.0-0-0 Dragon and I have absolutely no idea why that 'Qe1' ended up there. :-)
Pages
Your comment
By posting a comment you are agreeing to abide our Terms & Conditions